A prequel that fills in a story the audience already half-knows faces a particular danger: it has to be a complete film in its own right while also connecting cleanly to everything that comes after, and if it rushes to hit all its obligatory marks, it ends up gesturing at depth it never has time to earn. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is a good film caught in exactly that bind. Arriving a week after a revisit to The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes reaffirmed how high that prequel set the bar, this follow-up clears a slightly lower one, undone not by any failure of craft or ambition but by the simple fact that it does not give itself enough room. There is a great version of this movie, and you can see it straining to get out from under a runtime that cannot hold it.
Sunrise on the Reaping goes back twenty-four years before Katniss, to the fiftieth Hunger Games, the Second Quarter Quell, and tells the story of how a young Haymitch Abernathy became the broken man audiences first met mentoring District 12 decades later. Reaped into an arena designed to be deadlier than any before it, Haymitch fights to survive alongside his fellow District 12 tribute Maysilee Donner while the Capitol’s machinery grinds around them. Joseph Zada plays young Haymitch, and Mckenna Grace, Ralph Fiennes, Jesse Plemons, Elle Fanning, Kieran Culkin, and Kelvin Harrison Jr. also star. Francis Lawrence directs.
This needed to be two films, or a miniseries, because almost everything the movie wants to do gets shortchanged by the clock. The arena, which should be the centerpiece, feels compressed, its ideas raced through rather than explored, and the relationship between Haymitch and Maysilee, which the story leans on for its emotional weight, never gets the room to develop organically. Their bond is established in a single sharp beat, Haymitch turning up at her family business, him getting along fine with her sister, and Maysilee kicking the door to the room she's in shut in his face upon seeing him. The film needs them to be close, so they simply are, the connection happening because the plot requires it rather than because we watched it form. The same compression flattens the Covey, the traveling musician community woven through District 12’s identity and tied directly to Katniss’s own father, whose funeral and song provide one of the film’s loveliest moments. The Covey matters enormously to this world, and the film pushes it to the margins, a choice that stings more because the brief glimpses of it are so good.
That compression bleeds into the arena’s missed opportunity, too. The Hunger Games have always played with the question of what is real and what is manufactured, and this film’s arena literalizes it, a place where the water is poisoned and the animals are engineered to kill, where nothing can be trusted. The book is far more visceral than the film allows itself to be, and watching the sanded-down version, you find yourself wondering whether an R rating might have let the movie lean into the horror of it rather than gesturing at it. What is on screen is visually accomplished, the design of the arena is a strength, but it feels like the restrained edit of a harsher story.
The other real weakness is the recasting, and it is instructive because the film shows you both how to do it and how not to. The challenge of a prequel is that several of these characters have been played memorably before, and the new performers have to decide whether to imitate or reinvent. The ones who imitate suffer for it. Joseph Zada is clearly working to channel Woody Harrelson’s Haymitch, a proto-Harrelson performance that comes through more in some scenes than others and lands as stilted when it does, and Kelvin Harrison Jr. has the same problem as Beetee, audibly modulating his voice toward Jeffrey Wright’s cadence in a way that does not quite work. The contrast is Ralph Fiennes, who declines to imitate anyone. His President Snow is neither Donald Sutherland’s nor Tom Blyth’s but a distinct, bitter, angry iteration all his own, and it is excellent precisely because he is playing a character rather than an impression. Kieran Culkin threads the needle well too, giving an earlier, rougher, meaner Caesar Flickerman that nods to Stanley Tucci without copying him, a version of the man before he smoothed himself into the showman we know. The lesson sits right there in the ensemble: reinvention works, imitation strains.
Where the film is strongest is in its handling of propaganda and the manufacturing of narrative, which is the most thematically alive thing in it. The movie is pointedly interested in how the Capitol constructs the story it wants told, and it makes a smart structural choice in withholding the cutaways to the world outside the arena that the earlier films used so freely. It's interesting because it is rare that you see something like this, a structural decision within the movie that could go either way and either decision would have been good. In this case, we don't see what the audience is seeing so getting Haymitch's live reaction to the Capitol's version of events is heartbreaking, yet playing with the dramatic irony of Haymitch doing what he can in the arena would have been just as interesting.
The ending is where the adaptation stumbles most clearly against its source. The book closes on a recurring invocation of Poe’s “The Raven,” the poem that gives Lenore Dove her name and threads through the whole story, and the film replaces that resonant reprise with a more literal montage, Haymitch surveying everyone he has lost as time passes, the movie explaining to you what he is seeing rather than trusting the image. The reprise would have been more powerful for its restraint; the on-the-nose version drains the moment of the weight it should carry. There are smaller omissions that register too, the absence of the beat where Haymitch visits Lucy Gray’s grave among them, each a thread the book wove that the film, pressed for time, had to cut.
Sunrise on the Reaping manages the difficult feat of blending the visual language of The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes with that of the original four films, bridging a prequel and a main series that look quite different, and it does so seamlessly rather than landing in an awkward in-between. The world feels bigger and more fully realized here than it ever has, and the familiar comfort of slipping back into the pageantry and rhythm of a Hunger Games movie is still potent. For all its compression, the film does the thing it most needed to do, which is make you feel the tragedy of how this specific person became the ruin Katniss would one day meet.
Sunrise on the Reaping is a strong, affecting entry held back by a runtime that could not contain its ambitions, a film that needed to be bigger to do its story justice and settled for being merely good instead of great. The arena is undercooked, the Covey is sidelined, and too much happens because the plot demands it rather than because the film earned it, but Fiennes is superb, the propaganda thread is sharp, and the whole thing is carried by the weight of knowing exactly where this road ends. It is not quite the equal of Ballad, which remains the franchise’s high point, but it is a worthy companion to it. See it, and then wish, as I did, that there had been more of it.
